Sign in
Marty's Pizza Pasta & Subs
About
- 4.7 ( 41 reviews)
- $$, $$$
| Day of the Week | Opening Hours |
|---|---|
| Monday | 10:30 - 22:00 |
| Tuesday | 10:30 - 22:00 |
| Wednesday | 10:30 - 22:00 |
| Thursday | 10:30 - 22:00 |
| Friday | 11:00 - 23:00 |
| Saturday | 11:00 - 23:00 |
| Sunday | 12:00 - 21:00 |
Cuisines
- π Italian
- π Pizza
Dining Options
- πΊ Seating
- βΏ Wheelchair Accessible
- π₯‘ Takeout
- π½οΈ Table service
- π· Serves Alcohol
- πͺ Highchairs Available
- π Delivery
- π± Lunch
- π½οΈ Dinner
Recommended Reviews
4.7
william wiltsey
Pizza has always been great! Consistently well made, savory ingredients and sizes to fit any family. The service has been timely considering fresh made and the staff are always attentive and polite.
Deb Schlehlein
Pizza is always great. We like to sit in Patty's section. We get the large Deluxe Works so we can take half home.
Zoraida Esquilin
Great Ambiance, Great Service, Even better Food! The Mozzarella Sticks are to die for, and there Marinara Sauce is excellent..You can tell Fresh Mozzarella is used in EVERYTHING!! We will definitely be back soon.
Michael Brodhagen
3 generations of my family have been visiting Marty's over the years. We keep coming back for the awesome pizza and friendly family atmosphere. Always consistent and great service and pizza.
sophie mueller
Awesome atmosphere and great pizza. Service was amazing!
Tony McCutchan
The pizza was awesome, the sub sandwich was amazing and the service was exceptional. However, the Alfredo was dry and uninspired (-1 star). Stick with the pizza and you will not be disappointed.
Shade Wolf
Delicious local treat, I can't wait to go back there!
Andy McNutt
Γ’β¬ΒͺGreat local pizza spot. The decor is a bit dated, but the wait staff was friendly and attentive and the food was very good. The pizza crust isnΓ’β¬β’t too thick or thin (itΓ’β¬β’s just right) and they are quite generous with the toppings. We ordered an XL for 4 adults and barely finished half of it. All in all, great pizza at a very reasonable price. Γ’β¬Β¬
Sara Mapes
We love Marty's!!! We mostly go for the best mozzarella smothered chicken parmesan!!! So much cheese and so much sauce and a great portion!
Garry Low2
It used to be great. The crust was alot thicker than it used to be. It gives it a different taste, which isn't as good. The chicken Alfredo and garlic toast were pretty good.
Lawrence Russ
I drive many, many miles to come here when I want quality thin crust. One warning: absolutely do not get the meat lovers pizza (don't remember the name) unless you like an overload of excessively over the top meat! If you think more meat is a treat, then this place is hard to beat! Γ°ΕΈΛβ
Google User
Great pizza. A good tasting and solid crust to support the heavy toppings. Don't let the height of the box throw you off, it is a heavy pizza. The veggies are fresh, the sauce ratio is good, and plenty of cheese. I would recommend to others and I will return again myself.
Leslie Manske
Best pizza, ever! We've been customers forever. Their pizza is the best. Their sauce is amazing. Garlic bread is way better than Mama Mia's. Super value, as priced are insanely low and the quality is great.
H G
Great pizza and apps, service was fast food was hot.
Paul Lucht
Great pizza and service been going for years
Eric Svatik
Awesome restaurant awesome Pizza good pricing for what you get. The same price you pay for round pizzas at other places you get a square pizza which acts do you get more pizza from because it's square is not round I hear their advertisements on radio all the time my wife and I decided to give it a try and it was really good food well worth the trip into Brookfield
Krista Dunn
I love this pizza. Marty's has been my all time favorite since childhood. The sauce has great flavor, crust is cooked perfectly, and the toppings are fresh.
Bozhana Markova
Since 1957 and the same taste good pizza!
Doug Roska
Very easy location to get into. Very welcoming and friendly environment. The eggplant and pizzas are really delicious. Great place to enjoy a meal.
Susan Belongia
Absolutely the Best pizza happy birthday Ryan and we'll be back again and again! Great servicer as well.
Jim Heath
All good, would've have given 5 stars if there were a free dessert for the birthday girl who was ten that day... (like the good old days)
Jamie Walton
I always enjoy going here. I think its got a oldschool feel to it which I like. Service isn't bad not great in my opinion but food is always spot on.
Cobra257
Was good food. We liked the cheese curds, wings, and pizza. Excellent service. Their philly sub was ok
Mark D. Kennedy
Great place to eat Pleasant atmosphere friendly service fast service! Just an all-around great place to eat have a good conversation with friends family and if you have to do a little business great place to take a person.
Mary Murdock
Best pizza in town. Never disappoints
Larry Silver
This place has the best pizza anywhere. It is rectangular and great. Every time I visit Milwaukee, I there once. Or more. Last night I had pizza and a side of meatballs and sausage. I love this place. Go on weekdays as it is not as busy
Ruben Esquilin
Iv found my new Italian Food restaurant, Great service clean Bathroom
Jay Alan Ungart
My waitress had to deal with a picky table and a table with some unruly kid who would not sit down. Despite dodging the the little sh*t legt and right she handle everything efficiently. The portions were enormous. I can eat big, but the food made two meals for me. Maybe 3.Good food, good prices, be respectful to the staff.
Jeff Honeyager
Every time I go there I'm taken back to my childhood (my reason for spilling coke on myself). Great pizza!
Gina Lenzen
Love their daily specials, very old place though. You order the pizza by the foot.
Quinn Schwartz
Solid food on the cheap! The chicken Alfredo we got was great! And the homemade bread garlic bread was awesome
J. Seidler
Great family atmosphere. Fine dining with great staff. Would recommend bringing family and friends for the party size pizza 14"x36"!
Madison Mabin
We drive 30 mins to get this pizza. The service is superior, the pizza tastes how you wish all pizzas taste. Try and and fall in love.
Wayne Barnes
Went here in the 60s and loved it. Now recommended to my friends from New Zealand. They are there eating the pizza and I am in New Zealand looking at their photos. How crazy is that?
connie tarbah
I ordered a pizza online the other day. I had never been there before so I first asked the location and the person I talked to was a bit nasty. I then asked if they had a special and again she want helpful. I just ordered a pepperoni pizza. The good points, the pizzas was done on time and tasty.
TYRONE BARNES
Wonderful place. Food is excellent. Service is great you gotta try it. If they had 10 stars on here I would rate it a ten
Todd Strauss
I love the pizza here. Good place for a night out with the family.
Patti Bunch
Really good pizza! Toppings are piled high!Plan on eating half as much as you usually do!We literally ate 1/3 of what we ordered!
Sherry Gac
The BEST pizza ever! Have always loved their pizzas! Very flavorful! Can't wait to go back! Clean restaurant and restrooms!
Bishop Kenya Harris
Great place for family gathering. Food is outstanding and the service is top notch
Karrie Anderson
This place is the best! We only come here about once a year after visiting Six Flags. But it has become tradition! The food is fantastic, the service is superb, the price canΓ’β¬β’t be beat! 5 stars! Definitely recommend!